Planning a trip to Indianapolis and looking for the best Airbnb Indianapolis Rentals? Well, you’ve come to the right place, because my list of the best Airbnbs in Indianapolis guarantees a first-class experience during your stay in “The Crossroads of America”!
But I’ll be honest. I had never really thought about Indianapolis as a destination. But after compiling this list of the best Airbnbs in Indianapolis, I have to say I’m blown away! The city is interesting and diverse, and the Airbnb rentals are some of the most highly-rated I’ve seen thus far.
Once nicknamed “Naptown” for its reputation as a slow-paced destination, Indianapolis has transformed itself into an up-and-coming destination for singles, couples and families, with so much to see, do and experience.
It also has a ton of other nicknames. Circle City. The Crossroads of America. Railroad City. But most often, the city is simply referred to as “Indy”.
As the major U.S city nears a population of one million, now is the time to experience Indy for yourself. In a top AirBNB to boot!
My list of the best Airbnb Indianapolis vacation rentals ticks all the boxes for style, space and substance, and I’ve chosen stays across a broad range of neighborhoods so you can explore the city on your terms.
So without further adieu…
Quick Breakdown Of The Best Airbnb Indianapolis Rentals
Keen to click and book your dream Indianapolis stay as easily and quickly as possible? I’ve shortlisted the best 5 Vrbos & AirBNBs below, which are selected to suit a range of traveling styles, budgets and group sizes.
- The Best Overall Vacation Rental Indianapolis – Downtown Serenity | Minutes to Mass Ave
- The Best Luxury Vacation Rental Indianapolis – Downtown Luxury Penthouse
- The Best Cheap Indianapolis Vacation Rental – Studio B @ Keystone at the Crossing
- The Best Family-Friendly Indianapolis AirBNB – Modern Duplex in Charming Downtown Neighborhood
- The Best Indianapolis AirBNB For Solo Travelers – Hip Condo on Mass Ave Downtown
I’ve included lots of helpful videos about Indianapolis throughout this blog to make planning your visit even easier. Be sure to check them out. Meanwhile, stay tuned until the end of this blog for a list of some other inspiring U.S travel blogs you may want to check out!
1) Downtown Penthouse
The Best Luxury Indianapolis Vacation Rental
Location: Downtown Indianapolis
Price: $343 avg. per night
Sleeps: 4-10 (2 bedrooms/2 bathrooms). This is a 2BR/2 bath private penthouse and the villa’s other units are also available for rental.
Location, location, location. That and the lavish interior make this my pick for best luxury vacation rental in Indianapolis! This posh and private penthouse is placed one block away from Lucas Oil Stadium and within walking distance to downtown, making it perfect for couples, family gatherings, weddings, sporting events, or concerts. The “Villa on Meridian” was built in 1890 and has since been totally renovated while maintaining its rustic charm. You can rent this penthouse separately, or in combination with various equally impressive listings in the villa in order to accommodate larger groups.
Guest review: “We absolutely loved our stay here! We rented both the main house and the penthouse for a group that was attending a conference in Indianapolis, and we couldn’t have been more pleased!! This is a beautiful, old home with lots of character and yet plenty of modern conveniences. We will definitely stay here again!!!”
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Credit: Vrbo
2) Studio B @ Keystone at the Crossing
The Best Cheap Indianapolis Vacation Rental
Location: Washington Township
Price: $113 avg. per night
Sleeps: 3 (2 bedroom/2 bath)
This is my pick for the best cheap vacation rental in Indianapolis due to the ample space it provides at an unbeatable price point, as well as the artistic touches throughout. The space has two bedrooms, high speed WiFi and smart TVs, workspace, surprisingly large kitchen with all new appliances, and plenty of space for you to spread out and relax while remaining a short distance away from downtown and various awesome attractions. If you’re looking for a budget vacation rental to share with family or friends but don’t want to sacrifice comfort, this is the place for you!
Guest review: “This space is exactly as the pictures show: modern, clean, and cozy. Two great TVs, a nice kitchen, a beautiful bathroom and great decor are added bonuses. The best was comfy. Superb communication with the owner as I had a lot of questions on my arrival. A great place and I’d definitely stay again and recommend it.”
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Credit: Vrbo
3) Downtown Serenity | Minutes to Mass Ave
The Best Overall Vacation Rental Indianapolis
Location: Fall Creek Place
Price: $179 avg. per night
Sleeps: 5 (3 bedrooms/2 bathrooms)
There’s something about light-filled open plan homes that really do it for me, and that’s just one of the reasons that this serene stay is my pick for the best overall vacation rental in Indianapolis! Refurbished hardwood, marble, and classic tiles accent the various bright and tranquil spaces in this home, which are just an added bonus when considering the location, modern amenities/appliances/electronics, and decent price for the quality of accommodation. Make yourself at home and enjoy the neighborhood, which boasts music venues, bars, takeaway and cafes, and upscale eateries. If you’re not entirely sure what Indianapolis has to offer, making this Vrbo property your home away from for a few days is the perfect way to explore the “Railroad City.”
Guest review: “Beautiful apartment. It was exactly like the pictures plus more that the pictures don’t show. The apartment was extremely clean and even had very subtle touches like some fruit snacks and the toilet paper was folded lol. Very close to everything that Indianapolis has to offer. Elizabeth was super nice and very responsive and understanding. If she does the same for all of her properties then I recommend any that she has.”
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Credit: Vrbo
4) Chic 1br Apt | Heart of Downtown
Location: Mile Square
Airbnb Plus: No
Superhost: Yes
Price: $50+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/23772535
You couldn’t get a place closer to the heart of Indy than this one, and this stylish one-bedroom abode is a listing you can’t miss out on! Nestled right in Downtown Indy’s bustling Business District, the apartment is updated, modern and neat. Anything you could hope to see in the city is right nearby, including Circle Centre, Indianapolis Convention Centre and Victory Field. And at such an affordable price, who can resist?
Guest review: “This place is the perfect downtown Indy location! We could literally see the top of the Christmas lights from Circle Center out the living room window, and we were able to walk everywhere. Nice little touches with the guest Roku to watch TV/Movies if you’re staying in, Keurig coffee machine, and a very comfortable bed.” – Natalie
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
5) On the Water in Indianapolis – Geist
Location: Geist
AirBNB Plus: No
Superhost: Yes
Price: $1000+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/27727921
You can get SO MUCH bang for your buck in Indy, so I went big when choosing the best luxury Indianapolis AirBNB. This lakefront four bedroom, four-bathroom home is picture perfect and kitted out with everything you could dream of. A hot tub, fire pit, gym, spacious interiors and a location right on the wildlife habitat of Geist Reservoir. This serene pocket of Indianapolis is just 12 miles to Downtown Indianapolis and is a tranquil retreat just a stone’s throw from the big smoke. While it may be one of the newer listings available, this might just be the best Airbnb in Indiana!
Guest review: “I can’t speak highly enough about our experience at this house. Holly, our host, was incredibly responsive and gracious from the moment I inquired about the listing. And helpful too!. The space itself is amazing. Gorgeous view of the lake, a big hot tub, a massage chair, and just a ton of space to kick back and relax in. Loved the deck and modern kitchen. Everything was incredibly clean, which made our stay all the more comfortable. I strongly recommend this house for your next stay in Indy. You’ll want to stay an extra night!” – Charles
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
6) 3BR 2BA Downtown Luxury Modern “SmartHome”
Location: Bates – Hendricks
AirBNB Plus: No
Superhost: Yes
Price: $50+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/34787927
Indy is value for money personified, and you can’t get more than this three bedroom home offers for such a low price! Modern and classically stylish, this historic smart home has been fully renovated and has an outdoor fire pit with seating for enjoying the chilly Indiana winters. The Bates-Hendricks neighborhood is super central, and is two miles or less to many major Indy landmarks, including the Convention Centre, Lucas Oil Stadium, Monument Circle and Bankers Life Fieldhouse.
Guest review: “We were in town with some of our employees for a business trip. The house offered so many amenities and was super spacious. We will definitely be staying there again on our next trip to Indy! Thanks again Robert for such a wonderful stay!” – Brooke
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
7) Modern Duplex in Charming Downtown Neighborhood
“The Best Family-Friendly Indianapolis AirBNB”
Location: Fletcher Place
AirBNB Plus: Yes
Superhost: Yes
Price: $120+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/25395050
Indy is a great U.S family destination and is a safe city with more things to see and do being added every day. Contemporary and beautifully presented, this AirBNB Plus verified two-bedroom duplex is a historic property that has been fully renovated with many stylish additions. Fletcher Place is a historical neighborhood in Downtown Indianapolis, just a mile from major landmarks including Lucas Oil Stadium. There’s also a huge variety of dining, drinking and entertainment establishments nearby. The best Indianapolis AirBNB for families without a doubt!
Guest review: “Very nice hip and chic interior details to match a hip and chic neighborhood. Great bars, restaurants, coffee shops and bakery in the neighborhood. Attention to detail in the kitchen. Coffee pods provided which was a wonderful surprise. Excellent communication by hosts. Would highly recommend!” – Judy
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
8) Hip Condo on Mass Ave Downtown
“The Best Indianapolis AirBNB For Solo Travelers”
Location: Mass Ave
AirBNB Plus: No
Superhost: Yes
Price: $75+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/4708881
A solo trip to Indy for business or pleasure is a great idea, and the city centre and its surroundings are generally safe for those visiting on their own. This crisp and bright one bedroom condo is centrally located and the best Indianapolis AirBNB for solo travelers. It has high ceilings, historic maple hardwood floors and a private porch with courtyard. The host even stocks the fridge for you with exceptional craft beer! The condo is right on Mass Ave, an Indy foodie and entertainment hotspot. The hip neighborhood has the best bars, live music venues, restaurants and tap houses in the city.
Guest review: “Carol and Andy were absolutely fantastic hosts! We booked this place along with another listing of Carol and Andy’s across the street at the same time for a girls weekend with six women. There was more than enough space between the two condos for all six to be super comfortable, and every detail was perfect. The place is stylish, it was clean as could be, and Carol and Andy are great communicators. And last but not least, the location can’t be beat! Right in the heart of Mass Ave, there was a whole girls weekend worth of activities within walking distance of both the condos, and Carol and Andy gave great recommendations for food, drink, and entertainment. We highly recommend staying here!” Russell & Kathleen
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
9) Relax and Spin Vinyl in Upscale Urban Cabin
“The Best Unique Airbnb Indiana”
Location: Kennedy King / Monon 16
AirBNB Plus: Yes
Superhost: Yes
Price: $50+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/24407205
Blending rustic and industrial design elements, this two-bedroom “urban cabin” is universally loved by AirBNB guests who have been lucky enough to stay here. A century-old completed renovated space, the AirBNB Plus approved cabin is located in the northeast Indianapolis neighborhood of Kennedy King / Monon 16, which is laid back and cool, with tons of great little cafes, restaurants and breweries to explore. It’s certainly a contender for the coolest Airbnb in Indiana!
Guest review: “There is no better description than “urban cabin” – nestled among the charm of Indy, Matt & Jess’s hip and cozy abode will have you feeling right at home. The personal touches and amenities are truly above & beyond your expectations. Enjoy your stay!” – Jess
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
10) Cozy Downtown Cottage, steps from the MononTrail!
Location: Monon 16
AirBNB Plus: No
Superhost: Yes
Price: $50+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/39585498
This beautiful little one-bedroom cottage is a 5 star rated fan-favorite Indianapolis AirBNB, and I’m sure you’ll feel the same. The newly renovated space is bright, open and cozy, with its own private front porch. The Monon 16 neighborhood is an up-and-coming Indy zip code, with a variety of coffee shops, restaurants and breweries nearby. Rent a bike and cycle along the Monon Trail, which connects you with so much this great city has to offer. To Mile Square in the heart of Downtown Indianapolis, it’s a 30-minute drive.
Guest review: “Josh was a wonderful host who responded kindly and quickly. The cottage is SO SUPER CUTE! It was very clean with nice touches. The cottage sits alone in an that is on the rise. It was quiet and secluded, hence the perfect getaway for us. We will definitely book again!” – Catrece
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
11) Walkable & Urban 1BR in Historic Lockerbie
Location: Lockerbie
AirBNB Plus: No
Superhost: Yes
Price: $50+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/23299692
Just blocks from hip Mass Ave, this bright and cheerful one-bedroom apartment is modern, spacious and features a private balcony overlooking a serene courtyard. The historic Indianapolis neighborhood of Lockerbie is a central hub, and there’s a range of great bars and eateries within walking distance. A neat and affordable AirBNB in Indianapolis.
Guest review: “Very clean place ! Would definitely recommend it if you want a quiet , comfortable get away ! ,Very nice host & they were able to respond whenever I contacted them about anything ! Would book again !Thanks for the amazing stay.” – Taniya
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
12) Lavish Lair off Mass Ave Downtown w/Garage Parking
Location: Lockerbie
AirBNB Plus: No
Superhost: Yes
Price: $250+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/28605959
This luxe two-bedroom loft is a designer’s dream, and so far it has achieved a perfect 5 star guest rating – and with good reason! The industrial, open-concept space has two bathrooms, an office, plush chandeliers and velvet furnishings – oh, and a stunning copper tub! The dream! Add to that a private patio with grill, and a perfect location in vibrant entertainment strip Mass Ave and you’re crazy if you don’t have an incredible stay here! It’d be an amazing Airbnb Indianapolis for parties or small get-togethers during the day, but since it’s a historic brick building and sound carries so no late-night parties are allowed. With it’s a beautiful design and incredible amenities, as well with a perfect 5-Star rating from 16 previous guests, it’s definitely one of the best Airbnbs in Indiana!
Guest review: “Thank you so much for your hospitality. This place was a dream- so much of a dream that we decided to extend our stay and are already seeking to come back. This is the most luxurious loft stay that we ever had – and we travel all over the world using Airbnb. The location is Central to the city and within walking distance of great restaurants. It offered the luxury and detail that we were seeking. The owner has considered every detail. We plan to visit again soon for another break away from our reality. Highly recommend.” – Jaileah
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
13) Walk to Cafes and Eateries from The Loft in Broad Ripple
Location: Broad Ripple
AirBNB Plus: Yes
Superhost: Yes
Price: $100+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/4501442
The laidback Indianapolis neighborhood of abroad Ripple is brimming with hip cafes, brew pubs and clubs, and if that all sounds good to you, this is the AirBNB for you! The stunning AirBNB Plus guest suite apartment boasts one bedroom, one bathroom and a beautiful freestanding claw foot tub, and the owners were inspired by a historic local barn to find their design niche. Reach Downtown in just 20 minutes. This perfect little space is one of Indy’s most popular AirBNB stays, and I’m quite frankly a little jealous of anyone who has stayed here so far!
Guest review: “My stay at this cute guest loft was superb! The decor was what initially drew me in and the amenities were so cute and thoughtful! Location is great, just a short walk to the heart of Broad Ripple. Deborah was super easy to get in contact with when I needed any help. It was perfect for my getaway. Thank you so much.” – Alyssa
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
14) Downtown next to Lucas Oil + Free parking & gym
Location: Downtown Indianapolis
AirBNB Plus: No
Superhost: Yes
Price: $70+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/24177619
This brand new, modern condo is ideal for those visiting Indy for both business or pleasure. The minimalist, two bedroom condo is spacious, stylish and couldn’t be more perfectly positioned. Walk to Lucas Oil Stadium and the Convention Centre, and it’s just a few minutes drive to Indianapolis Zoo and Children’s Museum. There’s also a plethora of restaurants and bars at your fingertips. Stay right in the heart of Indy and enjoy an easy, breezy visit.
Guest review: “Wonderful hosts and very responsive. The space is even better in person. We stayed one night, but wished we were staying multiple. The space was extremely clean, artfully decorated, and great for relaxing or entertaining. Minutes from many great locations in Downtown Indy. Easy parking at the unit. Great experience.” – Steve
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
15) Peaceful Urban Farmstay, 10 Minutes from Downtown!
Location: South Indianapolis
AirBNB Plus: No
Superhost: Yes
Price: $50+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/24657609
Visiting Indianapolis but a city pad isn’t really your style? Well, you’ll love this urban farmstay just 10 minutes from Downtown. Nestled on an urban three acre property, this two bedroom home has been revitalised and is now a firm favorite for AirBNB in Indianapolis! The working farm has tons of animals, a farm pooch and is a tranquil place to unwind just a short distance from the big smoke. It’s also pet friendly, so if you’re travelling with your own furry friend, both you and them will love it here!
Guest review: “Absolutely amazing place to stay! Kind hosts. A sanctuary of peace outside of the city. Would recommend it to everyone and will definitely plan my visits around availability here.” – Brianna
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
16) Indy Luxe Loft in Downtown Indianapolis
Location: Wholesale District
AirBNB Plus: No
Superhost: Yes
Price: $125+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/33158815
This warm and spacious “luxe loft” is yet another 5 star rated Indianapolis AirBNB – they really set the bar high here! The historical two bedroom loft has been updated, but has retained its exposed brickwork and wood beam ceilings that only add character. The open plan space is sparkling clean and located in the heart of Downtown Indianapolis – just one minute walk to Bankers Life Fieldhouse, and the Convention Centre and a five minute stroll to Lucas Oil Stadium.
Guest review: “If you are looking for a sparkling clean, urban, downtown stay in Indianapolis, this is the spot. It’s walking distance to tons of great restaurants and events. We stayed for a multi-day event held at Lucas Oil Stadium and the convention center – and we walked everywhere we went without any problems. Joni has everything you’ll need in the loft – including super comfy beds. We loved people watching from the huge windows overlooking the street and it was nice to have the convenience of a fully equipped kitchen when we needed it. We had a local grocery store deliver some things the day we arrived.” – Melissa
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
17) The Condo in Broad Ripple ♥
Location: Broad Ripple
AirBNB Plus: No
Superhost: Yes
Price: $100+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/7706104
Trendy Broad Ripple is just 15 minutes from Downtown Indianapolis, but the cultural district is a buzzing hotspot you need to check out. This eco-friendly, stylish two bedroom condo operates entirely on green energy, and the newly renovated space boasts a small courtyard. Be sure to explore diverse Broad Ripple, with its many bars, restaurants and cafes and its youthful vibe.
Guest review: “We really enjoyed staying at Deborah’s place. She went above and beyond in making us feel welcomed. Along with extra toiletries, she gave us a plate of home baked cookies. The location is close to a lot of yummy restaurants but her kitchen was well stocked for anyone who loves to cook as well. The place is very clean and the neighborhood is safe and quiet. We highly recommend this airbnb.” – Joyce
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
18) 2BR with Balcony Overlooking City and Canal!
Location: Upper Canal District
AirBNB Plus: No
Superhost: Yes
Price: $70+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/31020101
Located right on Indianapolis’ beautiful Canal Walk, this boutique two-bedroom apartment is stylish and spacious. Perched on the waterfront, you’ll enjoy a great outdoor lifestyle here where you can rent bikes or pedal boats. It’s less than 10 minutes drive to Downtown Indianapolis, Mass Ave, Indianapolis Zoo, Monument Circle and so much more!
Guest review: “Apartment is spotless and fully stocked with everything you need to feel right at home. Location is phenomenal – great view of the city skyline and canal. This is our second stay with the host in this complex and we couldn’t be more satisfied. The Casual Nomad team thinks of everything.” – Don
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
19) Tiny Urban Farmhouse on Wheels
Location: Zionsville
AirBNB Plus: Yes
Superhost: Yes
Price: $120+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/33359086
Wrapping up this list with yet another 5-star guest rated Indianapolis AirBNB! This unique “tiny house” is verified by AirBNB Plus and widely loved. It has one bed, one bath and stylish interiors with pops of turquoise that will brighten your day. There’s also an outdoor patio seating area to watch the world go by from. Charming Zionsville is 30 minutes from Downtown Indianapolis and has a cute Main Street with a variety of restaurants and stores to explore.
Guest review: “My husband and I were attending a concert in Indianapolis and found this adorable tiny house. We had always wanted to experience a tiny house and it didn’t disappoint. Every detail is perfect and is just as pictured. We loved Main Street in Zionsville and the surrounding area.” – Jill
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Indianapolis Tours & Experiences To Check Out
Photo Tour of Indianapolis
“We will meet in Indy and explore the city and attractions while stopping and posing for pictures along the way. We will hit places like Victory Field, Sailors and Soldiers monument and more! You’ll have memories to share from this experience in the form of high quality portraits”
https://www.airbnb.com/experiences/1358680
VIP Art Party- Wine & Mixed Media Canvas
“This particular experience includes a canvas and wine venue. Participants will be guided through a mixed media project from start to finish using broken wine bottles/glass, paint, and texture. You will walk away with a belly full of laughter, joy, and a completed mixed media art piece for your wall.”
https://www.airbnb.com/experiences/1247329
Amazing Indianapolis Scavenger Hunt Adventure
“Discover Indianapolis with Urban Adventure Quest, the interactive city tour. Let your smartphone be your guide on this three-hour adventure through the rich history of downtown Indy, among outdoor art, historic sites, and military memorials.”
Price: From $66 USD (3 hours)
Review: “We had a terrific time, the weather was great, our grandsons (8 & 12) were excited and the scavenger hunt kept us on the move.” – Sandy, United States
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Did I leave out any epic Airbnb in Indianapolis?
I do my best to choose only the best quality AirBNBs for my lists. If you are the host of a top Indianapolis AirBNB or have recently stayed in one you want to shout out, feel free to reach out to me via my email or socials and I’ll see what I can do to get you on the list!
Planning a trip to Indianapolis or the U.S.A?
While this list kicks off my Indiana and Indianapolis content that I plan on growing, I have so many great U.S.A travel blogs on my site that you have to check out. I recommend checking out the below American music festival lists, AirBNB lists and city guides for a range of American destinations!
- The Top 50 Music Festivals in the U.S.A
- The 15 Coolest & Best Airbnbs in Detroit For a “Motor City” Getaway
- The 17 Best AirBNBs in New Orleans For The Ultimate “Big Easy” Experience
- The 20 Coolest & Best Airbnbs in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
- The 23 Best Rap & Hip Hop Festivals in the U.S.A
- The 25 Biggest & Best Folk Music Festivals in the U.S.A
- 20 Gorgeous Glamping Southern California Places You Need to Experience
- The 17 Coolest & Best Airbnbs in Miami for the Ultimate Beach Getaway
- TOP 30 Airbnbs in California | From San Francisco to San Diego
Final thoughts on Airbnb Indianapolis Rentals…
Indianapolis is a cool, interesting city that definitely deserves a visit! There’s so much to do here for children and adults alike, and it’s rapidly becoming a popular family-friendly destination. Have an epic trip!
Great list! I think you missed one though 😁