Airbnb Block Island | 13 Best Vacation Homes & Cottages Rental

Heading to Rhode Island and looking for the best Airbnb Block Island has to offer? Well, let your search stop here. I have put together a list of only the best Airbnb homes, cottages, and apartment rentals in Block Island.

This island – in the state of Rhode Island – promises long beach days, great restaurants, and lots of adventure. Whether you spend your days exploring the island by bike or lazing on the beach, you’ll need a great place to rest your head.

Airbnb is a great way to book your accommodation; you often get more unique options and have access to local hosts with the best tips. I have put together a list of the best Airbnb’s in Block Island to cater to everyone’s travel needs.

Okay, so let’s dive straight into the best Airbnbs. And if you are planning on a coastal adventure through Rhode Island, then check out the best Airbnbs in Newport, RI.

---

Quick Breakdown of Best Block Island Airbnbs 

In a rush? Check out the ultimate top 5 Airbnbs in Block Island. If you are looking for a large home for a family vacation or a cozy spot for a couples weekend getaway, you’ll find it here.

Check out the spots below; you’ll find something suited to your budget and travel needs. So get browsing and start booking your next beach getaway to Block Island.

• Best Block Island Rental Home – FARM HOUSE (ocean views & animals)
• Block Island Airbnb with the Best Views – Hip Saltbox with Breathtaking Views
• Best Block Island Apartment Rental – Mermaid House
• Most Unique Airbnb in Block Island – Ross House
• Best Block Island Cottage Airbnb Rental – Oceanfront Cottage – 4 BR close to town

I have also added some great videos throughout my post. They are super informative and will really add value to your trip, so be sure to check them out as you are reading!

---

Top Picks for Airbnb Block Island RI

I have taken my time to find only the best Block Island Airbnbs, so without further ado, let’s dive straight into the list. Browse through the properties, and you’ll soon understand why they made the cut.

---

1) FARM HOUSE (Ocean Views & Animals)

Best Block Island Rental Home

Location: New Shoreham

Superhost: Yes

Price: $580+ USD per night

https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/17332746

This gorgeous 12-sleeper home is one of the best Block Island vacation rentals. It’s the perfect oasis for a vacation with a large group or a big family. The furnishings are sleek and modern, and you’ll fall in love with the large balcony and panoramic ocean views.

The well-equipped kitchen will ensure fun family nights and dinners around the table before lighting up the fireplace and getting cozy in the lounge, making this a great Block Island winter rental. This house is conveniently located just a five-minute walk from the island’s shops, restaurants, beaches, and ferry landing. 

Two of the rooms boast exquisite wooden four-poster beds, while the third room provides two singles beds for younger family members. There are also three queen sleeper sofas to accommodate the extra guests. You won’t want to leave this seaside rental.

View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability

Guest Review: “Paradisiacal place. Some in our party called it a Noah’s Ark experience. Very well equipped kitchen, comfortable pillows and mattresses (including the sofa bed). We would definitely go back.”

---

2) Hip Saltbox with Breathtaking Views

Block Island Rental with the Best Views

Location: New Shoreham

Superhost: No

Price: $600+ USD per night

https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/7535154

This uniquely shaped and designed home has breathtaking views and lots of privacy. Look to the south, and you will have unobstructed ocean views, and on the west, you’ll have an aerial view of Rodman’s Hollow.

This quirky home is a short walk away from some of the most secluded beaches on the island, as well as a freshwater pond, perfect for a summer’s day dip.

You’ll feel the relaxed and peaceful atmosphere throughout the four-bedroomed home. The large deck on the second floor is a great space for enjoying the sunset over a meal. There is a small kitchen area with utensils, however, please note that there is no oven/stove.

Also, to add to the charm of this house, there is also an outdoor shower that is great for rinsing off after long adventurous days on the beach.

View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability

Guest Review: “We have stayed in several different properties on Block Island and this had by far the best view of all. We enjoyed the deck immensely. Dean responded very quickly to any inquiries we had.”

---

3) Mermaid House

Best Block Island Apartment Rental

Location: New Shoreham 

Superhost: Yes

Price: $300+ USD per night 

https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/35579892

This immaculate two-bedroom apartment is quaint and cozy and makes a great Block Island apartment rental. This spot is perfect for a young family or couple, with an airy master room and a second room with bunk beds.

The cottage has a peaceful feeling, and you’ll wake up to the sound of the birds and the ocean every morning. The apartment is within walking distance of the Block Island Nature Conservancy’s Greenway Trails and Cooneymus Beach.

Fire up the charcoal grill and enjoy a barbeque out on the deck. Except for a stove/oven, you’ll find everything else you need in the kitchenette.

View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability

Guest Review: “Perfect spot for an island getaway, the apartment is clean and comfortable and just a short distance to town. Highly recommend!”

---

4) Ross House

Most Unique Airbnb in Block Island

Location: Mohegan Bluffs – Southeast Corner of Block Island

Superhost: Yes

Price: $1557+ USD per night

https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/2986134

This gorgeous newly built home is modern, airy, and spacious. It is the perfect hideaway on the bluffs, and you’ll love every corner of this uniquely designed home. The building was designed to be light and open so that its guests can see, smell, and hear the ocean all day.

The tall windows don’t only show off views of the ocean during the day, but in the evenings you’ll be able to gaze at the stars and moon from the comfort of inside. This chic home sleeps seven guests in a secluded part on the southeast of Block Island.

View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability

Guest Review: “Great place, amazing view. Architecturally stunning and beautifully put together.”

---

5) Oceanfront Cottage – 4 BR Close to Town

Best Block Island Cottage Airbnb Rental

Location: New Shoreham

Superhost: No

Price: $799+ USD per night

https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/36234521

This is the quintessential beach cottage. Whitewashed walls and blue interiors create that familiar feeling of being by the sea. Close to the water’s edge, this cottage has great views and a beachy atmosphere.

This oceanfront cottage can comfortably sleep eight guests in its four bedrooms. There is a fully-equipped kitchen with everything you need to practice your master chef skills. Settle on the outside patio and enjoy your meal with the sounds of the waves crashing in the background. A true gem and perfect for a large group or family looking for a fun seaside getaway.

View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability

Guest Review: “Great host. Communication was fast and responsive. House was everything you want on Block Island. Excellent location near town with a breathtaking view!”

---

6) Shel House

Location: New Shoreham

Superhost: Yes

Price: $825+ USD per night

https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/8665619

This charming home is not only classic and homey but also an easy walk to the ferry, beaches, and downtown. This large Block Island home rental sleeps ten guests and is great for two families or a large group of friends. Three of the bedrooms have queen-sized beds, and the fourth is filled with two sets of bunk beds.

The renovated kitchen is a great spot to cook up a storm before settling on the patio to enjoy your meal. You’ll have an entire acre of manicured gardens all to yourself. And don’t forget to try out the outdoor shower and bath after a trip to the beach.

View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability

Guest Review: “Great location, amazing backyard, comfortable home, wonderful communication! Awesome time!”

---

7) The Windrose House, Walk to Town and Beach!!

Location: New Shoreham

Superhost: No

Price: $1200+ USD per night

https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/21977580

This idyllic home is situated atop a hill and is a short five-minute walk to the beach. The large back garden is perfect for active family days playing games and enjoying barbeques.

The open floor plan home is comfortable and spacious, with four bedrooms and bathrooms sleeping ten guests. Enjoy leisurely breakfasts in the kitchen’s large eat-in area before setting off for a day of exploring on the beach.

A great space for young families, with noise restrictions from 10 pm – 8 am on the shared property, you are guaranteed a quiet and peaceful retreat.

View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability

Guest Review: “This is a lovely home for a large family or group looking to spend some quiet time on Block Island. Our stay during the holiday week was lovely. Everyone really enjoyed the house and yard.”

---

8) Hilltop Happiness

Location: New Shoreham

Superhost: Yes

Price: $149+ USD per night

https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/17156510

This cozy private room is the perfect place for a couple looking for a convenient and comfortable place to stay on the island. With a near-perfect rating from all its reviewers, you won’t be disappointed by booking in here for a weekend getaway.

Close to both harbors, you are ideally located for different adventures on the island. Your hosts will go above and beyond to make your stay as comfortable as possible and provide beach chairs, towels, and a cooler to make your beach days even more enjoyable.

View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability

Guest Review: “Rich and Patty check off all the boxes when it comes to hosting an AirBnB. This one has it all and then some. Extremely satisfied with our stay and would highly recommend!”

---

9) The Sheffield House, Wildflower Room (Private Room Bed & Breakfast)

Location: New Shoreham

Superhost: Yes 

Price: $155+ USD per night

https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/13111019

A private room in this dreamy home is a great affordable option on the island. The house was built in 1888, in Queen Anne architecture – a style commonly seen in New England Airbnbs and homes. The home still maintains much of its character and charm. A lovely breakfast is also included in your stay, which you can enjoy on the wrap-around front porch.

The immaculate room has a comfortable queen-sized bed and a flat-screen  TV. You will share the bathroom with the one other bedroom on the floor. Located just a three-minute walk from the town and beaches, you’ll find this is a great spot to relax after a busy day on the island.

View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability

Guest Review: “Our second time staying here. This B&B is excellent. Clean, comfortable, and exactly as described. Breakfast is excellent and can be a real money saver from on island prices!”

---

10) Newly Built Modern Island Getaway – Island House

Location: New Shoreham 

Superhost: No

Price: $344+ USD per night

https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/46176369

Designed by an award-winning architect, this home is contemporary and modern. You will feel the warm and inviting atmosphere of the newly built house as you step inside. The double-story home comfortably sleeps eight guests in three bedrooms.

The spacious, open plan kitchen and dining area provide space for the whole family. Cook up a storm and enjoy the gorgeous sunset views from the balconies.

Relax around the fire pit in the evenings roasting smores and sharing in the memories you have made so far on Block Island.

View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability

Guest Review: “Matt build a very special house! 5 stars doesn’t do it justice. Great location, design and hospitality.”

---

11) New Shoreham Cottage

Location: New Shoreham 

Superhost: Yes

Price: $448+ USD per night

https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/28491223

This rustic wooden beach cottage is homely and perfectly located. The clean space is spacious and comfortable, accommodating eight guests. You will love how accessible the beach is, just a short three-minute walk from the cottage.

Enjoy the sea breeze on the outdoor deck while you eat and watch the sunset. Your hosts are gracious and welcoming, ensuring you feel at home in the cottage. It’s a fabulous spot for a group of friends or family vacations.

View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability

Guest Review: “We had an absolutely wonderful experience. Check-in is super easy. The deck is nice and spacious and it was great for enjoying your morning coffee and hanging out. Mansion beach is also a short walk, and it is a gorgeous spot.”

---

12) Newly Renovated Block Island rental with hot tub

Location: New Shoreham 

Superhost: No

Price: $350+ USD per night

https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/31917952

This large, newly renovated home is calling on all families looking for the ultimate beach getaway. After a long day on the beach, spend some time relaxing in the hot tub on the outdoor deck. Light up the grill and enjoy a family barbeque before settling into bed and getting ready for a new day of adventures.

You’ll be able to take a family or group of ten people, with two living rooms and a large yard, you’ll never feel as though there is not enough space. The home is also close to the Greenway Trails and Fresh Pond should you feel like exploring different areas.

Comfortable, spacious, and private, you can’t go wrong with booking this house.

View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability

Guest Review: “Great location, sparkling clean and very comfortable. Hope was responsive and has done a terrific job in creating a vacation rental that we will definitely come back to again and again.”