Are you looking for the best Airbnb Finger Lakes rentals available? Look no further than this list of picturesque properties that are guaranteed to help you find the perfect stay!
The Finger Lakes constitute a gorgeous region of New York State. Renowned for their natural beauty and unspoiled landscapes, this group of 11 lakes offers a wealth of opportunities for exploring nature.
The region is also New York’s wine country, and many charming wineries are found sprinkled throughout this highly scenic viticultural area.
If you’re traveling to the Finger Lakes and looking for unique New York accommodation, Airbnb is a great option. Whereas hotels all seem to be the same, Airbnbs are so wonderfully different. Each property is infused with local charm, which allows you to better appreciate the area you’re staying in.
Quick Breakdown of the Best Aibnb Finger Lakes & Vacation Rentals
To get you pumped for the full list of Finger Lakes rentals, take a look at the top five properties the region offers.
- Best Finger Lakes Vacation Rental For Families – Fallbrook Cove: sunny lakefront family cottage, sunsets, kayaks, walk everywhere
- Best Luxury Finger Lakes Vacation Rental – Waterfront, 138 ft Private Beach, Sunset View, SmartTV, Sleeps 24
- Best Cheap Finger Lakes Vacation Home – Private Rustic Cabin Now Open
- Best Seneca Lake Cabin Rental For Friends – Seneca Lake Cabin w/Incredible Views, Beach & Dock
- Best Finger Lakes Airbnb on the Water – LAKEFRONT LOFT W/PRIVATE DOCK
One last thing, below every other Airbnb you’ll find a short video that provides local insight and information. Hit the play button to learn a little bit more about the area.
Note: Due to the closure of the Airbnb Associates program, some of the properties listed have been changed to other booking platforms (which can have lower rates and less cleaning/service fees!
Credit: PaulMassiePhoto
Top 18 Airbnbs in Finger Lakes Region, New York
Let’s get into the full list of Airbnbs. Whether you’re looking for large houses to host a friend/family reunion, or quiet cabins on Seneca Lake for a couples retreat, you’re sure to find the place that suits your vacation needs.
1) Fallbrook Cove: sunny lakefront family cottage, sunsets, kayaks, walk everywhere
Best Finger Lakes Vacation Rental For Families
Location: Canandaigua
Price: $750+ USD per night
Families staying at this Finger Lakes home have given it a resounding five stars – and I’m sure you will too! The four bedroom Canandaigua home is situated right on the lake in a charming historic town with tons of fantastic restaurants, parks and brew pubs. The beautiful home features country cottage interiors, a fenced-in lakeside lawn and deck and so much more! A stay here comes with the use of two free kayaks which you can take out on the lake, and this cute little town is easily explored on foot. There is ski resorts in close proximity, as well as a range of top wineries.
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Guest Review: “The photos don’t do the cottage justice.. The cottage itself was very clean and well appointed. The views and easy access to the lake c ant be bear. It’s also in a great location to parks, restaurants, services, etc. Else was always available if we had a question and was a lovely host. We found this cottage at the last minute and decided to come on a whim. We had never heard of the lake or the area and we would return here in a heartbeat. What a wonderful family getaway!” – Stacey
Credit: VRBO
2) Waterfront, 138 ft Private Beach, Sunset View, SmartTV, Sleeps 24
Best Luxury Lakes Vacation Rental
Location: Rushville
Price: $2000+ USD per night
This luxury waterfront home in the Finger Lakes town of Rushville is the place to rest, rejuvenate and regenerate by the way. The six bedroom family home is a brand new build, and features beautiful interiors with multiple fireplaces and a custom kitchen, and a huge outdoor deck and a private 138 ft frontage with a private beach. It’s just a short drive into nearby Canandaigua for top local restaurants, hit the local ski resorts or explore the regions wineries. There’s so much to see and do in the Finger Lakes region of New York.
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Guest Review: “I cannot rave enough about this property and the quality of communication from the owner. John was so helpful and patient with my many questions. The view is spectacular and the house comes with every possible kitchen accessory or utensil you can think of. There is so much space that guests can spread out or gather together on the dock, patio or balcony. All the beds are comfortable too! The drive to town is so short and anything you need is less than 15 minutes away. I do not have a single complaint and only positive things to say. All our guests were speechless when they saw everything and our group can’t wait until the summer so we can come back. What an absolute gem, I am thrilled I found this property!!” – Amanda
Credit: VRBO
3) Private Rustic Cabin Now Open
Best Cheap Finger Lakes Vacation Home
Location: Prattsburgh
Price: $75+ USD per night
https://www.vrbo.com/3674010ha
Traveling to the Finger Lakes region of New York on a shoestring? This rustic cabin in the woods of Prattsburgh is budget-friendly and cozy, with compact interiors featuring a bathroom, kitchen appliances and an outdoor shower. There’s also a fire pit to cook dinner on just outside. This natural retreat is in close proximity to tons of great hiking trails, state parks, wineries, breweries and Keuka Lake. The nearby town of Hammondsport is charming, with gift shops and restaurants on the lake.
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Guest Review: “My boyfriend, dog, and I had such a great stay at Dave’s cabin, The Bird House. It was the perfect escape from the city. The surrounding woods were peaceful and the cabin was so cozy (even in the very low temperatures!) Dave made sure we were well stocked with supplies. There was plenty to do neat by when we weren’t sitting by the campfire like visiting the surrounding towns or hiking/ checking out the waterfalls. Dave is a lovely host & we can’t wait to come back for another visit.” – Eilene
Credit: VRBO
4) Skaneateles Carriage House Easy Walk to Village
Location: Skaneateles
Airbnb Plus: Yes
Superhost: Yes
Price: $220+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/plus/13462771
This Finger Lakes vacation rental is perfect for small families. The main bedroom has a comfy queen-sized bed for the parents, and the second bedroom has bunk beds for the kids. The furry members of your family (cat or dog) are also welcome.
The living room features two plush sofas and a flat-screen TV; the perfect setting for movie night. Thanks to the fully-equipped kitchen, you can easily make all of your meals. Or, if you’d prefer to dine outside, there’s a BBQ grill and outdoor furniture.
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Guest Review: “Kate and Sebastian were fantastic hosts. Beautiful carriage house and my entire family loved spending the holidays there. By far one of my best experiences! I would highly recommend.”
5) Cozy Lakeside Cabins on Seneca Lake #1
Location: Lodi
Airbnb Plus: No
Superhost: Yes
Price: $158+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/1893230
If you’re looking for Seneca Lake rentals for a romantic getaway, this one is hard to beat. The location is ideal for enjoying the area. It’s just a stone’s throw from the water, and a few miles from wineries, breweries, and restaurants.
Fun activities are just steps from your front door, like kayaking and paddleboarding. You’ll also have your own private deck that faces the lake. Inside the cabin, you’ll have all your vacation necessities, including a comfy queen-sized bed, a TV, WiFi, and a kitchenette.
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Guest Review: “Maura and her place went above and beyond our expectations- she thinks of the smallest things to make your stay more comfortable that you may have not thought of before leaving home. The views from the dock are amazing, and the cabin itself is just perfect to make a home away from home.”
6) 1875 Schoolhouse with Stunning Views & Modern Vibe
Location: Burdett
Airbnb Plus: No
Superhost: Yes
Price: $172+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/31236092
This unique Airbnb will add an extra special element to your trip. Set on top of a hill surrounded by 2.5 acres of peaceful property, you’ll stay in a renovated schoolhouse built-in 1875. It ties in modern comforts with its historic charm.
The kitchen is fully functional and features a fun coffee bar. Both of the bedrooms include comfy king-size memory foam beds. The living space has a record player, a fireplace, and vintage books; it’s the perfect setting for a bottle of wine after a fun day out.
Possibly the coolest feature is the outdoor heated igloo. The see-through structure allows you to get comfy and stay warm while stargazing.
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Guest Review: “This house is the cutest! The beds were so comfy, everything was cozy, the kitchen was incredibly well-stocked, and the scenery was amazing. We had a fantastic time here.”
7) Seneca Lake Cabin w/Incredible Views, Beach & Dock
Best Seneca Lake Cabin Rental For Friends
Location: Penn Yan
Airbnb Plus: No
Superhost: Yes
Price: $259+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/19316262
Peacefully perched on Seneca Lake, this cabin is all about enjoying lake-life. It’s just steps from the beachfront, where you’ll have access to a private dock, a beach cabana, a kayak, and a canoe. There’s also an upper deck with a gas grill and outdoor furniture.
Between the Master bedroom and spacious upstairs loft, there’s room for six guests, making the cabin great for groups of friends. With the Smart TV in the living space and a fully functional kitchen, you’ll have everything you need for vacation mode.
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Guest Review: “Jessica and Jackie’s house was the best we’ve stayed in at the Finger Lakes. It’s truly dreamy with the lake views and nestled in between the trees. It was perfect for our group and everyone loved it. Will definitely return!”
8) LAKEFRONT LOFT W/PRIVATE DOCK
Best Finger Lakes Airbnb on the Water
Location: Ithaca
Airbnb Plus: No
Superhost: No
Price: $189+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/7948022
This airy loft has floor-to-ceiling windows that shower you in sunshine and make you feel at one with nature. With the private dock and outdoor patio, you’ll be all set to enjoy a true lake vacation.
Hop on a kayak or stand up paddle-board and glide over the water. Or, relax on the outdoor hammock with a good book. If you like to stay in and cook, the kitchen has everything you need, including tea and locally roasted coffee. Between the three bedrooms, two bathrooms, and living space, the house can comfortably accommodate four guests.
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Guest Review: “This place is a true gem! Spectacular views and well-maintained house. We were lucky to see an amazing sunrise, and some snow in the same week. Keke & Kris are very responsive and provide everything you need to know.”
9) Waneta Lakeside Cottage
Location: Dundee
Airbnb Plus: No
Superhost: Yes
Price: $179+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/19585263
This charming cottage on Waneta Lake is perfect for enjoying the sights and sounds of nature. The spacious covered deck is perched right next to the water. It has outdoor furniture where you can dine and relax, and the steps lead down to private water access where you’ll find four kayaks.
Inside, the two bedrooms and one bathroom can accommodate four guests in total. There’s also a sitting area with a TV you can turn on during your downtime. And lastly, the full kitchen will sort out all of your dining requirements.
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Guest Review: “Wonderful!! Kent’s cottage is very comfortable and very thoughtfully designed. It was super easy to feel at home. You have everything you need and a wonderful view!”
10) Beautiful Cabin in Finger Lakes, NY
Location: Freeville
Airbnb Plus: No
Superhost: Yes
Price: $175+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/2880361
This Finger Lakes cabin rental will make you feel right at home. It’s nestled in a quiet location in the woods and features handcrafted furniture and rustic elements. You’ll have access to all of your modern conveniences, including a full kitchen, TV, and WiFi.
The bottom floor has a sleeper sofa in the living room, and the spiral staircase leads you to the loft, where you’ll find two double beds. The rural setting of the cabin allows you to soak in the solitude of nature, and you’ll be within walking distance to the hiking trails of the Yellow Barn State Forest.
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Guest Review: “Cute and spacious cabin in the woods. We loved the space by enjoying a fire outside and played games at the big kitchen table. Everything was very clean and the host left lots of information on travel in the area. We will definitely stay again in the future!”
11) The Loft on Cornell Street
Location: Ithaca
Airbnb Plus: No
Superhost: Yes
Price: $106+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/2645133
Located just one block from Cornell University, this cozy loft is a great option for one or two guests. It has a spacious open layout and a private entrance.
The bedroom is tucked into one corner and features a queen-sized bed. Opposite it, you’ll find a modern kitchen and dining room table. The living room has a fireplace and an oversized couch; it’s a very inviting space to return to after an eventful day out.
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Guest Review: “Highly recommend this loft! I love the open floor plan and location! It has the “away from busyness” vibe but is still close to where the action is! The host was great! She was available and attentive.”
12) Walnut Pond Retreat-Private House & Scenic Grounds
Location: Canandaigua
Airbnb Plus: No
Superhost: Yes
Price: $155+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/18864101
This dreamy Finger Lakes rental home is set in a refurbished 1870 farmhouse. It’s just steps from a large pond that features a private dock. You can enjoy the views while relaxing on the outdoor deck or inside looking out of the large bay window.
The cozy living room has a wood-burning fireplace for those cooler months, and the firewood is supplied by your host. The kitchen has everything you need for preparing your meals. Lastly, with two big bedrooms and two full bathrooms, you’ll be extra comfortable.
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Guest Review: “Jason’s house has all the comforts of home, a beautiful spot to view deer, ducks, and birds as they come to drink from the pond just outside the back window. It was cold and rainy during our stay, but the house was warm and cozy with a fire in the fireplace and a great kitchen to cook in!”
13) Experience Minka Life: Simple is Good
Location: King Ferry
Airbnb Plus: No
Superhost: Yes
Price: $111+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/20868727
Perched on the bank of Cayuga Lake, this Airbnb provides a serene escape. It’s the perfect setting for a quiet vacation; the only noise you’ll hear is the sound of the water lapping against the shore. You’ll have easy access to the water, and there are two kayaks for guests to use during their stay.
The space is ideal for two people, but there’s also a day bed that can sleep two more guests. The kitchen is fully stocked with all the supplies you’ll need for cooking something delicious. You can enjoy your meals on the patio overlooking the lake.
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Guest Review: “Truly a slice of peace on earth! Jude and Miles (the pup) made our stay absolutely wonderful. Is there anything better than falling asleep and waking up to the sound of waves? We had the best, best time!”
14) Lakeside Bunkhouse on Seneca Lake
Location: Geneva
Airbnb Plus: No
Superhost: Yes
Price: $364+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/13979030
Adventure awaits you at this beautiful Seneca Lake bunkhouse. Given its proximity to the water, you’ll have ample opportunities for boating, kayaking, swimming, fishing, and other water sports.
There are two bedrooms that can sleep up to seven guests. One room has a queen-sized bed while the other has two sets of bunk beds and a full-size futon.
The living room and kitchen are fully furnished with everything you need to stay comfortable indoors. They even feature large windows that look out directly onto the lake.
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Guest Review: “Wonderful place to stay while visiting Seneca Lake- convenient, comfortable, and beautiful views right by the water!”
15) Winery Cabin- Spectacular View
Location: Lodi
Airbnb Plus: No
Superhost: Yes
Price: $175+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/25801073
If you’re a wine drinker, look no further than this cozy cabin on Seneca Lake. Two wineries are within walking distance: Idol Ridge and Fossenvue winery. Your stay will include free tasting passes to both!
The full kitchen has everything you need to create a culinary masterpiece. After dinner, sit outside around the fire and roast some marshmallows. When it’s time to wind down for the day, the living room features plush sofas, and the bedroom has a comfortable queen-sized bed.
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Guest Review: “This was a perfect location for our wine tasting trip. Very comfy and well-equipped space with great views. Great communication and spotlessly clean. The tasting pack from Idol Ridge Winery was a very thoughtful touch. Loved the outdoor space with the deck and fire pit and plenty of space for our pup to run around. Highly recommend!”
16) Spacious Lakeview Cottage in Watkins Glen
Location: Watkins Glen
Airbnb Plus: No
Superhost: Yes
Price: $246+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/23498030
This Watkins Glen Airbnb is full of character. Built-in 1910, it features original woodwork, which provides a funky contrast with the blue-painted walls.
The three bedrooms can sleep a total of eight guests. Outside of the rooms, you can socialize in the large living room around the game table. Or, switch on the Smart TV or Atari game system. The kitchen is fully updated and includes complimentary coffee, tea, sugar, and creamer. Enjoy a glass on the front porch with a gorgeous view of Seneca Lake.
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Guest Review: “This is a warm and welcoming home with gorgeous views of Seneca Lake. Kate is a great host who responded quickly and provided many essentials that made for a relaxing stay. A great location for enjoying all of the great activities around Watkins Glen and the Finger Lakes.”
17) 1885 Fruit Packing House
Location: Hector
Airbnb Plus: No
Superhost: Yes
Price: $175+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/1062369
Set in the heart of the Finger Lakes region, this Airbnb lets you stay in a 5th generation family homestead that was built in 1885. The historic house is surrounded by panoramic views of vineyards and the gorgeous Seneca Lake.
The Master suite is on the second floor and features a full bathroom. Downstairs, you’ll find a cozy living room and a fully-equipped kitchen with a dining room table.
When you’re ready to explore the area, you’ll be in close distance to restaurants and wineries. You’ll also have local lake access for swimming, and the Finger Lakes National Forest is just a short drive away.
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Guest Review: “Lovely experience close to tons of wineries and restaurants. Tina was a very thoughtful host, leaving wine and cheese for us and tons of tips to enjoy the area. We wish we could have stayed longer!”
18) Vineyard Villa A
Location: Burdett
Airbnb Plus: No
Superhost: Yes
Price: $190+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/5443065
Located on Seneca Lake, along the winery and brewery trail, this Airbnb immerses you in all of the splendor of the Finger Lakes. The villa has two stories that supply all of the comforts of home.
The first floor has a snug living space, a full kitchen, a bathroom, and french doors that open up onto your own private deck. The second floor features a master bedroom and a balcony overlooking the lake. This Airbnb is the ideal place for a Finger Lakes getaway!
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Guest Review: “We absolutely loved this place! Amazing scenery and you can’t beat the sunset. Very clean and comfortable. Definitely recommend.”
Am I Missing A Finger Lakes Vacation Rental?
This region of New York is loaded with awesome Airbnbs, so it’s possible I may have missed one or two. If you come across any that deserve a spot on this list, shoot me a message and I’ll see what I can do about adding them in.
Other Recommended Reading Beyond Finger Lakes Rentals
If you’re looking for more USA travel inspiration, check out these other impressive Airbnbs posts.
- The 19 Coolest & Best Airbnbs in Maine For a New England Getaway
- The 17 Coolest & Best Airbnbs in Ocean City, Maryland
- The 20 Coolest & Best Airbnbs in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
- 17 Amazing Airbnbs in Newport, Rhode Island For a Perfect Getaway
- The 18 Coolest & Best Airbnbs in Washington D.C. For an Incredible Capital Visit
- 17 Amazing Airbnbs in Portland, Maine For an Ideal Getaway
- Top 12 Airbnbs Alternative to Try For Your Next Vacation Booking
- The 10 Coolest & Best Airbnbs in Boston For a Wicked Awesome Trip
- The 16 Best Brooklyn Airbnbs For the Coolest New York Experience
- The 15 Coolest & Best Airbnbs in Columbus, Ohio
Final Thoughts on Airbnb Finger Lakes, NY
While most people associate New York with New York City, the Finger Lakes region is just as worthy of a visit. It’s a beautiful area of the state that has a wonderful four seasons allure and plenty of charming properties to host your stay.
Whether you’re looking for Seneca Lake cabins or quiet vacation rentals along one of the Finger Lakes wine trails, you’ll find plenty of options.
